Skip to content

FIRST CHOICE CATERING

  • Weddings

  • Black Tie Events

  • Anniversaries

  • Graduations

  • Birthdays

  • Repasts

Any Gathering where Real, Good Food is desired!

  • All package pricing is per person

  • Minimum 20 servings, increments of 5 thereafter

  • Delivery and set up charge $20

  • Heavy duty plates and plastic flat ware available at an additional charge

  • Custom buffets for Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Weddings, Showers, & Funeral Luncheons.

  • Bartenders, servers, and/or chef available upon request

  • Chaffing equipment available

  • Dessert and Children’s menu available

  • Linens and premium serving ware available upon request

  • Ask about renting our dining room for special occasions

We customize the meal to fit your event and budget!

First Choice Catering - Premium Catering Options

Appetizers

Chips & Salsa$10Bruschetta / Antipasto Tray (serves 25)$45
Brushetta Crostini$151/2 Pan Meat Balls (BBQ, Garlic Parm, Sweat & Sour) $25
12 Caprice Kababs$16Mini Subs or Reubens $1 per
Meat & Cheese Tray (serves 20-30)$65Smoked Chicken Salad Croissants$2 per
Veggie Tray, Dips included (serves 25)$45Chicken Wings (BBQ, Buffalo, Garlic Parm.) $1 per
Seasonal Fruit Tray (serves 25)$55Ruramaki $.50 per
Baked Brie w/ Apples & Crackers$35

Salads

Half serves 20 to 30, Full serves 55

SaladHalfFull SaladHalfFull
Garden$25$45Tropical Fruit$35$55
BLT (Romaine, Tomato, Bacon, Mayo)$35$55Pasta (Southwest or Italian) $20$40
Caesar$35$55Macaroni$20$40
Garbage$40$55Potato$5/LB
Cole Slaw$20$40

Sides

Half serves 20 to 30, Full serves 55
Serving Utensils $.75 per person, Plates and Plastic $.50 per person

SideHalfFull SideHalfFull
Sugar Dill Carrots$25$45Au Gratin Potatoes -$55
Garlic or Bacon Green Beans, or Mixed Veggies$25$45Loaded Potatoes -$55
Mac & Cheese $35$55Grilled Summer Veggies -$65
Mostaccioli$25$45

Specialties

Chicken Giambotta (Chicken Breast, Pepper Sausage, Potatoes in Garlic Wine Sauce)*Petti Verdure (Alfredo w/ peas & ham)*
Beef or Chicken Fajitas*Chicken or Mushroom Broccoli Tetrazzini*
Stuffed Shells*Ribs (Cut in Single, 10-12 Per Slab)
$17 per slab
Roasted Pork w/ Stuffing or Dumplings
*Corned Beef Dinners (Potatoes, Cabbage, Carrots, Rye)$12.95 per person
Sauced Chicken Breast (Lemon, Greek, Marsala, Wine Garlic, Lime w/ Mango Salsa)$90

*prices for Specialties determined by selection and party size

First Choice Catering - Featuring the Irish Pig BBQ Packages

Cold Sides

Garden Salad w/dressingCole Slaw
Macaroni SaladPasta Salad (Italian or Southwest)

Hot Sides

MostacciloiMacaroni and Cheese
Potato WedgesVeggies

BBQ Special Package

Chicken Tenders, Pulled Pork, Cole Slaw, Baked Beans & Mac N Cheese  (comes with buns and sauce)

$9.95 per person

Hawaiian Luau

Sweet & Sour Chicken, Pulled Pork, Asian Cole Slaw, Hawaiian Rice & Fruit Salad

$11.95 per person

Entrees

Chicken Breast TendersItalian Beef
Italian Sausage and PeppersPolish Sausage and Kraut

By the Pan

By The PanHalf PanFull Pan By The PanHalf PanFull Pan
Chicken Breast Tenders(approx 40 Pieces) $40.00(approx 80 Pieces) $75.00Double Baked Mashed Potatoes (cheese, chive, & bacon)-$55.00
Macaroni & Cheese$35.00$55.00Italian Sausage-$60.00
Au Gratin Potatoes -$55.00

By the Pound

By The PoundPer Pound Price By The PoundPer Pound Price
Pork$11.95Italian or BBQ Beef$12.95
Brisket$14.95Corned Beef$12.95

1lb. makes 6 small hamburger bun sandwiches - Meat by the pound includes:  Bread/Buns, Au Jus or BBQ sauce, Peppers for Italian Beef